Why is it that whenever something comes up that involves the topics of Government and religion, invariably talking heads start regurgitating “Separation of Church and State! It’s in the Constitution!” (or some derivation thereof) impersonating experts in Constitutional Law. In reality, it’s regurgitating some easily memorized sound byte. Next to a complete disregard for proper spelling and grammar, it’s probably one of my biggest pet peeves.
Maybe I’m just a stickler, but whenever I hear that verbal vomit, like a fork on a chalkboard, it makes me wince in pain. Often literally.
Being a bit of an American History buff, I don’t recall ever seeing the phrase ‘Separation of Church and State’ anywhere in the Constitution, the Bill of Rights, or any of the other 17 Amendments. Yes, the phrase is used in some of Thomas Jefferson’s later writings, as well as some Supreme Court opinions, but it is not in the Constitution. Why this distinction? Because when pressed, the same talking heads cite the “First Amendment Rights”.
So what does the First Amendment say anyway?
Amendment I
Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.
That’s it in its entirety. Forty-five words. “Congress shall make no law…” Congress cannot establish a national religion, and they cannot prohibit anyone from practicing their chosen religion.
But nowhere does it state that the Federal Government must be fully and completely devoid of any and all religion. Most of the founding fathers were deists, believing in a God. They were trying to lay the groundwork for freedom OF religion, not freedom FROM religion.
Telling people what they can or cannot practice is a direct contradiction to the principles this Union was built on.
In my opinion, this also applies to all of those trying to remove any and all reference to God from every last public place, parchment, and promissory note (that last one being poetic license for ‘money’).
Why is that? Glad you asked. The Tenth Amendment, the last in the Bill of Rights:
Amendment X
The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.
Any powers not specifically given to the Federal Government by the Constitution inherently belong to the States or the People. If it’s not specifically spelled out here as a power of the Federal Government, then it is up to the individual States, if not you and me, and our friends and neighbors, to govern ourselves.
There’s nothing Unconstitutional about a statue, monument, the slogan ‘In God We Trust’, or The Pledge of Allegiance. ’So help me God’ wasn’t even in the Oath of Office initially, but every President since George Washington has uttered those words. If any of those specified which God, then it would most likely be a different story, but they don’t. Your city/county/state may have enacted laws to remove any and all mention of God, but a mention of God in and of itself is not Unconstitutional. And since 73% of Americans believe in a God or Supreme Being, I wonder- why are we as a society agreeable to removing any and all mention of ‘God’ to satisfy the (sometimes vocal) minority?
There are bigger issues out there right now that we could and should be concerning ourselves with. But if you’re going to (mis)quote the Constution, please take the time to not only read it, but to comprehend it.
End of rant.
Thanks for stopping by and letting me vent.
What do you think?
-Dan, a.k.a. @PHXPhoto